| Name | Nominee In | Recipient In: |
| Avenue Q Balagan Theatre | 2013 | |
| Cabaret Village Theatre | 2015 | |
| Chicago Village Theatre | 2013 | |
| Dick Whittington and His Cat Seattle Children's Theatre | 2015 | |
| Hedwig and the Angry Inch Balagan Theatre & Seattle Theatre Group | 2013 | |
| Into The Woods STAGEright | 2015 | |
| Jacques Brel is Alive and Well & Living In Paris 5th Avenue & ACT Theatre | 2015 | |
| Les Misérables Balagan Theatre | 2014 | |
| Les Misérables Village Theatre | 2014 | |
| Little Shop of Horrors 5th Avenue Theatre & ACT Theatre | 2014 | |
| Mary Poppins Village Theatre | 2015* | |
| Monty Python's Spamalot 5th Avenue Theatre | 2014 | |
| Next to Normal Balagan Theatre & Contemporary Classics | 2013* | |
| The Pirates of Penzance 5th Avenue Theatre | 2013 | |
| The Wild Party Sound Theatre Company | 2014* |
*People's Choice Nominee